Compound Income
  • Blog
  • Scores
    • Example
  • Portfolio
  • Resources
    • Check list
  • About
  • Contact



How to Score  Compound Income↑ Stocks Part 5 - Dividend Growth

27/8/2014

0 Comments

 
This is a slightly controversial metric to include as many believe and some studies have shown that buying growth stocks or focussing on historic growth is not necessarily a winning strategy. However, in income investing it can be appropriate if you are trying to secure a growing income which can protect both your income and capital in real terms. Other studies and as highlighted on this site show that compounding your income can also greatly increase your returns and speed the recovery from draw downs (declines).

So what is the evidence for looking at dividend growth? Well specifically in the UK in 2008 there was an interesting working paper titled Consistent Dividend Growth Investment Strategies by Gwilym, Clare, Seaton and Thomas from the Cass Buisness School. In the abstract from this they said:

"We investigate whether firms in the United Kingdom that have a long, uninterrupted history of dividend growth outperform the broader equity market. It is observed that firms with in excess of 10-years consistent growth have returned considerably more than the equity market as a whole, with the additional benefits of lower volatility and smaller draw downs. A size effect exists amongst these firms with lower market-capitalization firms demonstrating improved risk-adjusted returns."

They also highlighted some of the other research which suggests that looking at dividend growth history is a good idea as follows:

"There are a number of good reasons why investors should favour companies that have a consistent history of increasing dividends. 
  • Firstly, one of the components in Gordon’s (1962) constant growth valuation model is the growth term. It takes a much greater leap of faith to assume a future growth rate when there has been no precedent set in recent years compared to a stock that has a long-term growth rate already demonstrated. 
  • Secondly, Lintner (1956) observes that management only raise dividends when they believe that earnings have permanently increased. This implies that firms that continually increase their payments envisage a positive outlook for profitability. 
  • Thirdly, Barth et al (1999) show that firms with a pattern of increasing earnings have been accorded higher price-earnings ratios after controlling for growth and risk. Given that in the long-run dividends and earnings are inexorably linked, this appears to bode well for the valuations of consistent dividend payers. 
  • Finally, Arnott and Asness (2003) demonstrate that, in aggregate, higher dividend payouts are consistent with higher future earnings growth. Walker (2005) supports the case for investments in consistent payers. In the 10 years to April 2005, it is stated that a basket of US securities with at least 10-years of consistent dividend growth outperformed the S&P 500 by 3.28% per annum coupled with the advantage of two percentage points lower volatility."

Indeed S & P even produce what they call Dividend Aristocrat indices based on this concept and a number of ETF's have been launched based on these and other indices with a similar concept. See the link above for a useful site (buyupside) which details the US qualifiers and has lots of other useful free information for investors.

So it seems that there is some value in looking at dividend growth history although they found that it worked best in smaller and mid cap names, which again fits well if you are running a concentrated portfolio and not closet indexing. Indeed the authors of the above paper said: 

"The conclusion is rapidly drawn that for consistent dividend portfolios to be successful they should be formed on an equally weighted basis; otherwise there is no real advantage in diverting from the benchmark. The equal versus value-weighted issue might in itself explain some of the out performance of comparable US ETFs versus the market-capitalization approach of the S&P 500 described by Walker (2005)."

Thus dividend growth history is one of the factors I take into account when scoring Compound Income stocks. It could also be argued that this is another way of measuring or assessing quality as those companies with a long history of rising dividend presumably are well managed and have a business which can generate rising returns for shareholders over time. So in a way it follows on well from the operational quality measures I looked at in part 4. Similarly here a steadily rising profile is likely to indicate a better quality / managed business, whereas weaker or more cyclical ones are more likely to have pauses in their growth or even dividend cuts which obviously you would want to avoid.

With that in mind and with an eye to the future I also factor in the one year forecast dividend growth alongside the dividend history for a combined dividend growth score as I like to know that growth is still forecast and how it compares with the past. In the next part I'll look at another indicator which helps to back this up.

Finally, the other take away I had from this paper was the fact that they found that "a significant portion of the improvement in absolute return of the consistent dividend growth stocks can be attributed to the avoidance of non-paying firms."  So when compiling a list of Compound Income stocks to compare I make a point of generally excluding zero yielding stocks as I'm not interested in them and as the authors observed:

"The most immediate observation is the exceptionally poor performance of the zero-dividend firms, particularly those larger ones that were in the All-Share Index. Not only were returns comparatively low but also the volatility was much higher relative to the dividend paying firms. The maximum draw down was an eye-watering 85% for the All-Share constituents, with accompanying extreme Ulcer index levels." Ouch - buy zero yielding stocks if you like but I just say No ! 







0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Google+

    Archives

    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    32Red
    Aberdeen Am
    Admin
    A G Barr
    Alliance Pharma
    Alternative Telecoms
    AMEC
    Amino Technologies
    Amlin
    Anglo Pacific
    Asset Allocation
    BA Systems
    BATS
    Behavioural Finance
    Bellway
    Berendsen
    BHP Billiton
    Bloomsbury Publishing
    Bodycote
    Books
    Bovis Homes
    Britvic
    Catlin-group
    Central Asia Metals
    Centrica
    Character Group
    Cineworld
    Clarkson
    Commercial Property
    Compound
    Computacenter
    Connect Group
    Croda
    Currencies
    Demographics
    Diageo
    Diploma
    Directors Dealings
    Dividends
    Easyjet
    Economics
    Emerging Markets
    Emis
    Empiric Student Property
    Etfs
    Fairpoint
    Ferguson
    Ferrexpo
    Finsbury Foods
    Food Retailers
    Games Workshop
    Goid
    Greene King
    GSK
    Hargreaves Services
    Hays
    Headlam
    Hedge Funds
    Hill & Smith
    House Builders
    Howden
    HSBC
    IG Group
    Imperial Tobacco
    Indivor
    Inflation
    Insurance
    Intermediate Capital
    Interserve
    Investment Trusts
    It
    ITV
    James Halstead
    Jarvis Investment Management
    JLT
    Jupiter Fund Management
    KCOM
    Kingfisher
    Legal & General
    Maintel
    Man Group
    Market Timing Indicator
    Market Valuation
    Marston's
    Matchtec
    Media
    Merlin Entertainment
    Micro Focus
    Mining
    Mitie
    Miton Group
    Mondi
    Music
    National Grid
    N.Brown
    News
    Next
    Nichols
    Norcros
    Oil
    Paypoint
    Pennon
    Persimmon
    Personal Finance
    Pharmaceuticals
    Phoenix Group
    Photo Me
    Photo-Me
    Plus500
    Podcasts
    Polar Capital
    Politics
    Portfolio
    Portmeirion
    Provident Financial
    PZC
    Rank Group
    Reckitt Benckiser
    Renewable Energy
    Renishaw
    Research Papers
    Restaurant Group
    Retailers
    RM Group
    Rolls Royce
    RPC
    RPS
    Safestore
    Sainsburys
    Savills
    Schroders
    Scores
    SCS Group
    Sell Discipline
    Shareholder Yield
    Share Picks
    Short Interest
    Spectris
    Sprue Aegis
    SSE
    Stock Spirits
    S & U Plc
    TalkTalk
    Taptica
    Tax
    Technology
    Telecoms
    Tobacco
    Trading Ideas
    TSB
    TUI
    UK Market Update
    Unilever
    Utilitywise
    Value
    Victrex
    Vodafone
    VP.
    Water Utilities
    WH Smiths
    William Hill
    Wynstay
    XL Media
    XP Power
    Yield
    Zytronic

Powered by
  • Blog
  • Scores
    • Example
  • Portfolio
  • Resources
    • Check list
  • About
  • Contact
✕