Compound Income
  • Blog
  • Scores
    • Scores Presentation
  • Portfolio
    • Table of Returns
  • Resources
    • Check list
  • About
  • Contact



CIS Portfolio Q4 Screening

5/1/2016

0 Comments

 
Introduction
This was the third quarterly re-screening since the portfolio was started and I have to say it was one of the hardest so far. Firstly I had to fight typical behavioural biases as I was tempted to apply some valuation constraints and thereby take some profits in some of the big risers. However, since I have not done this up to now and the behavioural bias I'm trying to avoid is selling winners too soon, I resisted the temptation again this time, although perhaps I will apply them with a full re-screening at the annual stage. Any way the other reason I avoided this was that using the 80 threshold on the Scores also suggested a rather excessive 6 sales, 2 of which seemed reasonable, 2 which seemed 50 / 50 and 2 which didn't seem to make that much sense. Thus for this quarter I went with 75 as the cut off which meant the 2 sales that seemed reasonable to me went ahead which I'll discuss in the next section.

Quarterly Screening
As discussed above having used 75 I avoided selling Jupiter Fund Management (JUP) and Maintel (MAI) where there didn't seem to be that many changes or much justification for selling them, although the portfolio has two fund managers which might have justified selling Jupiter for diversification reasons. While the potential sales which I suggested were 50/50 trades would have been in Next (NXT) and Utilitywise (UTW). I say 50/50 because in the case of Next we know that trading is likely to have been weaker due to the mild weather this winter. The shares however have been weak in advance of the update this week, which is likely to be binary in so far as it could either be received badly or come as a pleasant surprise if it is not so bad. On balance I was therefore happy to retain it for now as it was only purchased last quarter, it remains a well managed business with good financials and the valuation is now more reasonable. In the case of Utilitywise as it has been such a volatile and disappointing stock for the portfolio I was personally itching to sell it. However, the recent update and further major supplier agreeing new terms suggests that some of the worries that have dogged it might be easing. So they both remain in the portfolio for now and as ever time will tell if that was a wise decision or not.

Sales
The two stocks that were sold as a result of scoring lower than 75 were Diploma (DPLM) - CIS 72, which has been flirting with the sale threshold for a while. It finally succumbed as they have seen downgrades, the valuation is no longer as attractive and their current forecast growth is now lower. I would say though that it remains a good quality, well managed business, so I wouldn't put you off running with it if you hold it as this sale is just as a result of the mechanical screening process. In a similar way IG Group (IGG) -  has also been sold as their dividend growth and cover scores have deteriorated, as have their estimate revisions leading it down to a CIS of 71.

Purchases
To replace these stocks I selected two of the highest scoring stocks which meet the normal screening criteria. The first one in an entertaining investment karma kind of way, given my recent comment about missing out on 50%+ gains in gambling stocks, is a stock called Zytronic (ZYT). This maker of larger robust touch screens is one which I bought myself last year and have made 50%+ on, so perhaps I shouldn't beat myself up too much if I do miss out on some CIS portfolio stocks? The reason I bought it and the CIS Portfolio didn't was because it failed the £50m market cap screen during most of last year, but I decided to buy it myself as one of the rare occasions when I stray into sub £50m market caps if I think the investment case is compelling. Thus, given it is up over 50% since I bought it, I would have a natural behavioural bias against buying it up here close to its all time high. But again as this is a mechanical process designed to overcome behavioural biases and as it is over a £50m market cap now with a CIS of 99,  I allowed it to buy it, even though the valuation is not as cheap as it was, but it is still reasonably attractive nevertheless.

The second purchase is a stock that I have featured in the past, Easyjet EZJ, which I suggested getting on board back in June 2015 when it was sub 1600p and which subsequently hit my 1800p target where you could have taken a decent profit out of it. However, as it now also scores 99 on the CIS and has some attractive valuation metrics I feel more comfortable about this purchase at 1740p. They seem well placed with their continuing expansion, low oil prices and increasing consumer incomes although I guess the increased terrorist threat recently could perhaps take the edge off of their progress. On that basis it will be interesting to see how these two buys pan out and whether the comfortable or the uncomfortable turns out to be best and if I'll regret not doing the other sales.

Summary & Conclusion
A difficult set of decisions for me this quarter in what is supposed to be an automatic detached process. However, I guess that underlines the fact that even with a quantitative system you still have to have some input into the trades that come out of the process and have some kind of sanity check unless you are going to follow the output blindly. In this case I have tried to apply some common sense as any fixed selling threshold might just throw up lots of marginal trades which might then cost so much that you will trade away your profits in frictional costs. Thus I have compromised to a certain extent to keep the trading costs under control as these now total around 1% of the starting capital so far, although the quarterly re screened portfolio has outperformed the original portfolio so far. So perhaps I have got the balance right as if I had allowed all the possible trades along the way with a fixed 80 score and strict valuation thresholds this may not have been the case.

This now leaves the Portfolio with a weighted average exposure to the CIS of 91 and some reasonable looking valuation stats of P/E Y1 14.7x, dividend yield Y1 3.2%, EBIT/EV yield of 8.4% and the forecast dividend growth for the portfolio is 11.5%. In terms of sectors as I have allowed it to go where it finds good scoring stocks and it therefore remains heavily overweight in Consumer Cyclicals and Industrials. While surprisingly perhaps for an income portfolio it has nothing in Energy, Basic Materials, Consumer Defensives, or Utilities, although as it is more of an income / growth process may be that is not such a surprise. In any event I tend to think more about what each of the individual companies bring to the portfolio and how they fit together rather than obsessing about sectors. I therefore try to avoid having two identical stocks in say the house building sector, while accepting that another stock like Howden say might be different but is exposed potentially to the similar economic sensitivities as a house builder, which at present are positive and worth being exposed to.

So there goes another quarter, hope you are finding the CIS Portfolio and the Scores useful in your investing and good luck for the year ahead.

Postscript
We have had the Next trading update today which was OK in the circumstances of the recent mild weather. Nevertheless they guided towards the bottom of their previous range as a result. Thus although not a profits warning as such it will lead to a few more small downgrades which may well reduce the score a bit more. Against that though they have announced another special dividend and the shares have fallen to around their indicated buy back price. So presumably they may resume some buyback which may support the price from here. Their outlook is for sales and profits growth in the range of 1 to 6% for the coming year which seems fine, if a little dull. Will continue to hold for the CIS Portfolio until the next quarterly / Annual screening due at the end of March / early April.



0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Google+

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    32Red
    Aberdeen Am
    Admin
    A G Barr
    Alliance Pharma
    Alternative Telecoms
    AMEC
    Amino Technologies
    Amlin
    Anglo Pacific
    Asset Allocation
    Auto Trader Group
    BA Systems
    BATS
    Behavioural Finance
    Bellway
    Berendsen
    BHP Billiton
    Bloomsbury Publishing
    Bodycote
    Books
    Bovis Homes
    BREXIT
    Britvic
    Catlin-group
    Central Asia Metals
    Centrica
    Character Group
    Churchill China
    Cineworld
    City Of London Investment Group
    Clarkson
    Commercial Property
    Compound
    Computacenter
    Connect Group
    Croda
    Currencies
    Demographics
    Diageo
    Diploma
    Directors Dealings
    Dividends
    Easyjet
    Economics
    Emerging Markets
    Emis
    Empiric Student Property
    Etfs
    Fairpoint
    Ferguson
    Ferrexpo
    Finsbury Foods
    Food Retailers
    Forterra
    Games Workshop
    Gateley
    Go Compare
    Goid
    Greene King
    GSK
    Hargreaves Services
    Hays
    Headlam
    Hedge Funds
    Hill & Smith
    House Builders
    Howden
    HSBC
    IG Group
    Imperial Tobacco
    Indivor
    Inflation
    Insurance
    Intermediate Capital
    Interserve
    Investec
    Investment Trusts
    It
    ITV
    James Halstead
    Jarvis Investment Management
    JLT
    Jupiter Fund Management
    KCOM
    Kingfisher
    Legal & General
    Lloyds Bank
    Maintel
    Man Group
    Market Timing Indicator
    Market Valuation
    Marston's
    Matchtec
    Media
    Merlin Entertainment
    Micro Focus
    Mining
    Mitie
    Miton Group
    Moenysupermarket
    Mondi
    Moneysupermaket.com
    Music
    National Grid
    N.Brown
    News
    Next
    Nichols
    Norcros
    Oil
    Page Group
    Paypoint
    Pennon
    Persimmon
    Personal Finance
    Pharmaceuticals
    Phoenix Group
    Photo Me
    Photo-Me
    Plus500
    Podcasts
    Polar Capital
    Politics
    Portfolio
    Portmeirion
    Provident Financial
    PZC
    Qinetiq
    Ramsdens Holdings
    Rank Group
    Reckitt Benckiser
    Renewable Energy
    Renew Holdings
    Renishaw
    Research Papers
    Restaurant Group
    Retailers
    RIO
    RM Group
    Rolls Royce
    RPC
    RPS
    Safestore
    Sage
    Sainsburys
    Savills
    Schroders
    Scores
    SCS Group
    Sell Discipline
    Shareholder Yield
    Share Picks
    Short Interest
    Somero
    Spectris
    Sprue Aegis
    SSE
    Stock Spirits
    S & U Plc
    TalkTalk
    Taptica
    Tax
    Technology
    Telecoms
    Tobacco
    Trading Ideas
    TSB
    TUI
    UK Market Update
    Unilever
    Utilitywise
    Value
    Victrex
    Vodafone
    VP.
    Water Utilities
    WH Smiths
    William Hill
    Wynstay
    XL Media
    XP Power
    Yield
    Zytronic

    googleda4a17cac6d02bb9.html
    File Size: 0 kb
    File Type: html
    Download File

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Blog
  • Scores
    • Scores Presentation
  • Portfolio
    • Table of Returns
  • Resources
    • Check list
  • About
  • Contact